AI can't replace this


When I started out as an analyst in the banking industry, one of the biggest training I had was learning how to pull out key facts and crunch financial data. I went through reading pages upon pages of the annual reports, trying to learn how to analyze numbers.

A senior analyst told me: “Willie, that’s how you learn the ropes.”

Later on, I remembered one evening, walking home with a private investor friend to the MRT station after dinner, my friend said: “Willie, you know a good analyst doesn’t make you a good investor right?”

That stuck with me. And got me thinking hard for a while.

I soon realized this: It’s one thing to learn about financial data. But if you want to win in investing in he long term, you need to combine financial analysis with the qualitative aspects of investing. You need to understand why people buy. And why do they keep on buying. And that’s understanding the laws of human behaviour.

I used to painfully “copy and paste” financial data from annual reports to an excel spreadsheet. Today, an AI tool can easily read a 200-page annual report and give you the entire analysis before you get your cup of morning coffee. So, if everyone has AI at their fingertips, numbers alone can’t give you that edge. What can?

Well, what’s going to take effort is learning about human behavior.

This is because behaviour drives action, action drives transactions, transactions drive business.

And investing in businesses is all about knowing why people buy these businesses’ products and services.

Warren Buffett understood this well. Two years ago, while seated at the Berkshire Hathaway AGM, Buffett said something that struck me. Back then, when I was at the front seats of Berkshire Hathaway AGM May 2024...

He said while he may not know the technology behind Apple. But he knows why people buy the iPhone.

In fact, Apple shares are now Warren Buffett's largest holding in Berkshire Hathaway. He compares the iPhone as a much more valuable product than a car.

He said: Apple is in a position with consumers, where they’re paying maybe $1,500, or whatever it may be, for a phone. And the same people pay $35,000 for having a second car. But if people have both an iPhone and a car, and you ask them which one they give up? They would give up the second car.

It’s interesting. Because both Warren Buffett and Charlie Munger didn’t know how to make candies, or try to figure out the secret recipe behind Coca-Cola. Or even try to understand the network infrastructure behind American Express.

But these are the same companies that Berkshire Hathaway held massive stakes in their investment fund.

I learnt this with my own money

In 2015, I owned shares in Food Empire Holdings, one of the biggest sellers of instant mix coffee in Russia under a popular MacCoffee brand. When the Russian-Ukraine crisis unfolded back then, the rouble currency collapsed. Food Empire shares got hammered. And I was sitting on paper losses of more than 36%. Ouch.

The numbers looked terrible - the Russian rouble and impact of the Russian crisis then impacted its business. I was terrified.

Instead of panic selling, I had asked a different question. Have people in Russia stopped drinking their coffee? I knew Russians drink their coffee. I also knew Russia is one of the largest coffee consumers in the world today. And I knew Food Empire sold its coffee in a cheap 3-in-1 packet. This makes everyday purchases much easier when money is tight. I picked up signs people were still having coffee as part of their daily habits.

The answer was clear. Food Empire’s numbers might have looked terrible during the Russian war, but its business hadn't deteriorated overnight. People were still drinking coffee sold by the company.

In 2016, shares of this Russian company began climbing back. In two short years, the stock began to recover....

How to be a student of human behaviour

What I learnt is you need to be a student of human behaviour. What’s a good way to do this? A great way is to start observing why people buy certain products and services. Then ask what drives them to take out their wallets. And buy more of that same stuff. As investors, this gives us deep insights to why some companies have predictable profits, durable moat – why some companies don’t.

Learning financial analysis is the first step to investing.

To win in investing, we have to start thinking about laws of human behaviour.

Don't you agree?

Sometimes, investing can be simple.

- Willie Keng, CFA

Founder, DividendTitan.com

Dividend Titan

Read more from Dividend Titan

Hey, Willie here! We're starting to see a US stock rotation. By Occam's razor, Mr. Market's recent sell-off comes down to this: mid-term elections are over and US President Donald Trump is trying to salvage his presidency ending the Iran war. Perhaps that's why we're seeing a shift from growth to value stocks, from US stocks to global stocks. I've also unpacked my views on Singtel, Genting Singapore and ST Engineering on today's MoneyFM89.3 Market View. Click here to listen to Market View...

“Willie! Ravi on the line… Looking for you.” My colleague shouted across the desk. “Not again.” I called out. It was the third time in two weeks Ravi had called. To be fair, I enjoyed talking to him. He’s a smart man. The calls were because of an Indonesian mobile phone retailer's Singapore dollar bond default. This was at least ten years ago. I once met Ravi for coffee along Selegie Road. Well-built with a black moustache. He speaks with a certain confidence and eloquence with a heavy...

I'm taking a slow Friday with Lance Alexander on MoneyFM89.3. Unpacked Jensen Huang quitting Nvidia, got a closer look into Singapore banks' recent 3Q earnings update (found this interesting point), and more... Click here to listen to Market View Have a great weekend ahead! Sometimes, investing can be simple. - Willie Keng, CFA Founder, DividendTitan.com